| 1549 | COLE | Thomas, M.A. | |
| 1559 | MORE | Ralph | |
| 1575 | STUBBERSFIELD | Rowland | |
| 1585 | SYMONDSON | Thomas | Symondson was a member of the Common Council.In 1621 he was excused attendance at their meetings on account of his great age, and his presence being also required at the school. |
| 1628 | ELMSTONE | Thomas, M.A. | |
| 1646 | LAMBE | Thomas | |
| 1647 | BRIGHT | William | |
| 1648 | THOMAS | Richard | Dismissed in 1650 |
| 1650 | WYSE | William | |
| 1651 June | PEEKE | Daniel | Peeke's election was not confirmed |
| 1651 Oct. | HASSARD | Nathaniel, M.A. | Hassard died the following November |
| 1652 | TURNER | John | |
| 1662 | ALTUM | William | |
| 1664 | LAW | John, M.A. | Dismissed in 1691 |
| 1691 | CANNAN | Horsmonden, Rev., M.A. | Fellow of King's College, Cambridge. Elected during the pleasure of the Corporation. |
| 1696 | WALWYN | Charles, Rev., M.A. | Fellow of King's College, Cambridge. Elected during the pleasure of the Corporation. |
| 1741 | BYE | Deodatus, Rev., M.A. | Resigned in 1746 |
| 1746 | RUSSELL | John, Rev., M.A. | Elected by a Vestry Meeting of the Inhabitants |
| 1764 | POLHILL | William, Rev., B.A. | |
| 1777 | CHERRY | Thomas, Rev., B.D. | Fellow of St. John's, Oxford |
| 1795 | EVANS | John, Rev., M.A. | |
| 1805 | ALFREE | Edward Mott, Rev., M.A. | |
| 1818 | COLE | Benjamin Thomas Halcot, Rev., M.A. | |
| 1822 | HEAWOOD | Edward, Rev., M.A. | |
| 1828 | HARRISON | Thomas, Rev., M.A. | |
| 1844 | SPURGIN | John, Rev., M.A. | Fellow of Clare Hall, Cambridge |
| 1857 | GOULD | George Masters, Rev., M.A. | |