| 1548 | Heeley | Richard | | 1654 | Allen | James |
| 1549 | Heeley | Richard | | 1753 | Argles | Edward |
| 1550 | Basse | Richard | | 1791 | Argles | Edward |
| 1551 | Mowerst | John | | 1797 | Argles | Edward |
| 1552 | Tilden | William | | 1802 | Argles | Edward |
| 1553 | Mowerst | John (Charter forfeited in 1554) | | 1845 | Argles | Henry |
| 1559 | Goar | Thomas | | 1855 | Argles | Henry |
| 1560 | Green | William | | 1815 | Argles | John |
| 1561 | Beale | John | | 1718 | Argles | Thomas |
| 1562 | Balsar | Robert | | 1731 | Argles | Thomas |
| 1563 | Mowerst | William | | 1749 | Argles | Thomas |
| 1564 | Smyth | William | | 1779 | Argles | Thomas |
| 1565 | Busbridge | James | | 1788 | Argles | Thomas |
| 1566 | Austin | Nicholas | | 1858 | Arkcoll | Charles |
| 1567 | Lutwick | Clement | | 1868 | Arkcoll | Charles |
| 1568 | Ippenbury | Ambrose | | 1566 | Austin | Nicholas |
| 1569 | Balsar | Robert | | 1578 | Balsar | John |
| 1570 | Catlin | Richard | | 1562 | Balsar | Robert |
| 1571 | Golding | Nicholas | | 1569 | Balsar | Robert |
| 1572 | Staylett | John | | 1633 | Banks | Caleb |
| 1573 | Lee | Richard | | 1644 | Banks | Caleb |
| 1574 | Beale | Thomas | | 1656 | Banks | Caleb |
| 1575 | Haseden | William | | 1614 | Banks | John |
| 1576 | Downe | William | | 1622 | Banks | John |
| 1577 | Maplesden | Gervase | | 1581 | Basden | Thomas |
| 1578 | Balsar | John | | 1550 | Basse | Richard |
| 1579 | Edmonds | Thomas | | 1580 | Bateman | John |
| 1580 | Bateman | John | | 1624 | Beale | Ambrose |
| 1581 | Basden | Thomas | | 1637 | Beale | Ambrose |
| 1582 | Milles | John | | 1561 | Beale | John |
| 1583 | Franklyn | James | | 1666 | Beale | John |
| 1584 | Maplesden | Edward | | 1574 | Beale | Thomas |
| 1585 | Tynley | Robert | | 1662 | Beaver | Michael |
| 1586 | Symmonds | William | | 1639 | Bigg | John |
| 1587 | Franklyn | James | | 1660 | Bills | Richard |
| 1588 | Fremlyn | John | | 1650 | Bills | Richards |
| 1589 | Green | Gabriel | | 1777 | Bishop | George |
| 1590 | Smythe | Richard | | 1786 | Bishop | George |
| 1591 | Franklyn | Thomas | | 1778 | Bishop | William, Sir |
| 1592 | Maplesden | George | | 1787 | Bishop | William, Sir |
| 1593 | Romney | John | | 1799 | Blake | John |
| 1594 | Heeley | Stephen | | 1806 | Blake | John |
| 1595 | Salmon | Matthew | | 1682 | Bliss | Thomas |
| 1596 | Green | John | | 1734 | Blunt | John |
| 1597 | Goar | Robert | | 1772 | Brenchley | John |
| 1598 | Plommer | William | | 1781 | Brenchley | John |
| 1599 | Spencer | James | | 1816 | Brenchley | John |
| 1600 | Highwood | Richard | | 1670 | Brooke | Robert |
| 1601 | Fisher | Walter | | 1648 | Broughton | Andrew |
| 1602 | Franklyn | James | | 1659 | Broughton | Andrew June 1660, Richard Bills |
| 1603 | Green | Gabriel | | 1809 | Burgess | George |
| 1604 | Maplesden | Edward | | 1821 | Burgess | George |
| 1605 | Romney | John | | 1808 | Burr | George |
| 1606 | heeley | Stephen | | 1565 | Busbridge | James |
| 1607 | Green | John | | 1665 | Callant | John |
| 1608 | Highwood | Richard | | 1680 | Callent | Garret |
| 1609 | Fisher | Walter | | 1696 | Callent | Garret |
| 1610 | Maplesden | Richard | | 1708 | Callent | Garret |
| 1611 | Swinnock | Thomas | | 1570 | Catlin | Richard |
| 1612 | Reeve | Thomas | | 1703 | Chandler | Matthew |
| 1613 | Crompe | John | | 1712 | Chandler | Matthew |
| 1614 | Banks | John | | 1721 | Chandler | Matthew |
| 1615 | Green | Gabriel | | 1741 | Charter forfeited no Mayor in office | |
| 1616 | Maplesden | Edward | | 1863 | Clifford | James |
| 1617 | Heeley | Stephen | | 1873 | Clifford | James |
| 1618 | Fisher | Walter | | 1669 | Collins | Daniel |
| 1619 | Swinnock | Thomas | | 1632 | Collins | John |
| 1620 | Golding | Robert | | 1814 | Corrall | Philip |
| 1621 | Crompe | John | | 1661 | Cripps | John |
| 1622 | Banks | John | | 1667 | Cripps | John |
| 1623 | Maplesden | Gervase | | 1671 | Cripps | John |
| 1624 | Beale | Ambrose | | 1613 | Crompe | John |
| 1625 | Stanley | Thomas | | 1621 | Crompe | John |
| 1626 | Swinnock | Thomas | | 1645 | Crompe | Thomas (died during office) succeeded by Robert Swinnock |
| 1627 | Reeve | Thomas | | 1679 | Curteis | Francis |
| 1628 | Franklyn | James | | 1695 | Curteis | Francis |
| 1629 | Maplesden | Richard | | 1707 | Curteis | Francis |
| 1630 | Swinnock | Robert | | 1715 | Curteis | George |
| 1631 | Wood | Robert | | 1716 | Curteis | George |
| 1632 | Collins | John | | 1729 | Curteis | George |
| 1633 | Banks | Caleb | | 1807 | Cutbush | Henry |
| 1634 | Marshall | Samuel | | 1866 | Cutbush | Horace R. |
| 1635 | Maplesden | Gervase | | 1817 | Day | John |
| 1636 | Gilliat | George | | 1793 | Day | Thomas |
| 1637 | Beale | Ambrose | | 1803 | Day | Thomas |
| 1638 | Swinnock | Thomas | | 1810 | Day | Thomas |
| 1639 | Bigg | John | | 1831 | Day | Thomas |
| 1640 | Jeffery | Martin | | 1843 | Day | Thomas |
| 1641 | Stanley | Thomas | | 1879 | Day | William, Jr. |
| 1642 | Withinbroke | Robert | | 1576 | Downe | William |
| 1643 | Swinnock | Robert | | 1672 | Dunning | John |
| 1644 | Banks | Caleb | | 1862 | Edmett | George |
| 1645 | Crompe | Thomas (died during office) succeeded by Robert Swinnock | | 1867 | Edmett | George |
| 1646 | Maplesden | Gervase | | 1842 | Edmett | Thomas |
| 1647 | Ruse | James | | 1579 | Edmonds | Thomas |
| 1648 | Broughton | Andrew | | 1860 | Ellis | Charles |
| 1649 | Taylor | Thomas | | 1872 | Ellis | Charles |
| 1650 | Bills | Richards | | 1878 | Ellis | Charles |
| 1651 | Ongley | George | | 1836 | Ellis | Charles, elected in January |
| 1652 | Saunders | John | | 1864 | Ellis | Charles, Jr. |
| 1653 | Heath | Robert | | 1601 | Fisher | Walter |
| 1654 | Allen | James | | 1609 | Fisher | Walter |
| 1655 | Troughton | Jonathan | | 1618 | Fisher | Walter |
| 1656 | Banks | Caleb | | 1663 | Fletcher | Thomas |
| 1657 | Ruse | James | | 1723 | Flint | Richard |
| 1658 | Maplesden | Gervase | | 1735 | Flint | Richard |
| 1659 | Broughton | Andrew June 1660, Richard Bills | | 1685 | Fowle | John |
| 1660 | Bills | Richard | | 1583 | Franklyn | James |
| 1661 | Cripps | John | | 1587 | Franklyn | James |
| 1662 | Beaver | Michael | | 1602 | Franklyn | James |
| 1663 | Fletcher | Thomas | | 1628 | Franklyn | James |
| 1664 | Goar | John | | 1591 | Franklyn | Thomas |
| 1665 | Callant | John | | 1840 | Franklyn | Thomas |
| 1666 | Beale | John | | 1846 | Franklyn | Thomas |
| 1667 | Cripps | John | | 1588 | Fremlyn | John |
| 1668 | Heeley | Gervase | | 1636 | Gilliat | George |
| 1669 | Collins | Daniel | | 1664 | Goar | John |
| 1670 | Brooke | Robert | | 1597 | Goar | Robert |
| 1671 | Cripps | John | | 1559 | Goar | Thomas |
| 1672 | Dunning | John | | 1571 | Golding | Nicholas |
| 1673 | Venman | Thomas | | 1620 | Golding | Robert |
| 1674 | Harris | Arthur | | 1589 | Green | Gabriel |
| 1675 | Wood | Samuel | | 1603 | Green | Gabriel |
| 1676 | Lanes | John | | 1615 | Green | Gabriel |
| 1677 | Walker | George | | 1596 | Green | John |
| 1678 | Weldish | William | | 1607 | Green | John |
| 1679 | Curteis | Francis | | 1560 | Green | William |
| 1680 | Callent | Garret | | 1702 | Greenhill | John |
| 1681 | Saunders | Robert | | 1776 | Hammond | Tobias |
| 1682 | Bliss | Thomas | | 1782 | Hammond | Tobias |
| 1683 | Peirce | George | | 1784 | Hammond | Tobias |
| 1684 | Salmon | Robert | | 1674 | Harris | Arthur |
| 1685 | Fowle | John | | 1751 | Harris | John |
| 1686 | Marshall | Thomas | | 1755 | Harris | John |
| 1687 | Wright | Joseph, a Baptist Minister, elected Oct. 1688 Robert Saunders | | 1575 | Haseden | William |
| 1688 | Wattell | Richard | | 1851 | Haynes | William |
| 1689 | Osborne | Alexander | | 1861 | Haynes | William |
| 1690 | Heeley | Richard | | 1869 | Haynes | William |
| 1691 | Weaver | William | | 1877 | Haynes | William |
| 1692 | Swinnock | Robert | | 1653 | Heath | Robert |
| 1693 | Wood | Samuel | | 1668 | Heeley | Gervase |
| 1694 | Weldish | William | | 1719 | Heeley | Gervase |
| 1695 | Curteis | Francis | | 1732 | Heeley | Gervase |
| 1696 | Callent | Garret | | 1548 | Heeley | Richard |
| 1697 | Peirce | George | | 1549 | Heeley | Richard |
| 1698 | Salmon | Robert | | 1690 | Heeley | Richard |
| 1699 | Marshall | Thomas | | 1594 | Heeley | Stephen |
| 1700 | Osborne | Alexander | | 1606 | heeley | Stephen |
| 1701 | Weaver | William | | 1617 | Heeley | Stephen |
| 1702 | Greenhill | John | | 1600 | Highwood | Richard |
| 1703 | Chandler | Matthew | | 1608 | Highwood | Richard |
| 1704 | Weeks | Stephen | | 1871 | Hills | John H. |
| 1705 | Sherbourne | James | | 1832 | Hills | Walter |
| 1706 | Weldish | William | | 1764 | Holloway | Richard |
| 1707 | Curteis | Francis | | 1766 | Holloway | Richard |
| 1708 | Callent | Garret | | 1770 | Holloway | Richard |
| 1709 | Peirce | George | | 1714 | How | John (died Jan. 17, 1715, aged 80), succeeded by William Weldish |
| 1710 | Marshall | Thomas | | 1874 | Hughes | Henry |
| 1711 | Osborne | Alexander | | 1824 | Hughes | John N. |
| 1712 | Chandler | Matthew | | 1830 | Hughes | John N. |
| 1713 | Sherbourne | James | | 1747 | Hunter | Edward elected in June |
| 1714 | How | John (died Jan. 17, 1715, aged 80), succeeded by William Weldish | | 1838 | Hussey | William |
| 1715 | Curteis | George | | 1568 | Ippenbury | Ambrose |
| 1716 | Curteis | George | | 1640 | Jeffery | Martin |
| 1717 | Rand | William | | 1796 | Jefferys | William |
| 1718 | Argles | Thomas | | 1852 | Joy | Henry Winkles |
| 1719 | Heeley | Gervase | | 1790 | King | John |
| 1720 | Tomlyn | John | | 1800 | King | John |
| 1721 | Chandler | Matthew | | 1740 | Kirby | Daniel |
| 1722 | Pett | Marriott (died Nov. 13), succeeded by John Blunt | | 1763 | Lacy | Robert |
| 1723 | Flint | Richard | | 1676 | Lanes | John |
| 1724 | Page | Stephen | | 1853 | Laurence | William |
| 1725 | Mussery | Richard | | 1865 | Laurence | William |
| 1726 | Wattell | William | | 1573 | Lee | Richard |
| 1727 | Whetland | Daniel | | 1567 | Lutwick | Clement |
| 1728 | Weldish | William | | 1584 | Maplesden | Edward |
| 1729 | Curteis | George | | 1604 | Maplesden | Edward |
| 1730 | Rand | William | | 1616 | Maplesden | Edward |
| 1731 | Argles | Thomas | | 1592 | Maplesden | George |
| 1732 | Heeley | Gervase | | 1577 | Maplesden | Gervase |
| 1733 | Tomlyn | John | | 1623 | Maplesden | Gervase |
| 1734 | Blunt | John | | 1635 | Maplesden | Gervase |
| 1735 | Flint | Richard | | 1646 | Maplesden | Gervase |
| 1736 | Weldish | William | | 1658 | Maplesden | Gervase |
| 1737 | Weldish | William | | 1610 | Maplesden | Richard |
| 1738 | Weldish | William | | 1629 | Maplesden | Richard |
| 1739 | Stevenson | Samuel | | 1819 | Mares | John |
| 1740 | Kirby | Daniel | | 1826 | Mares | John |
| 1741 | Charter forfeited no Mayor in office | | | 1833 | Mares | John |
| 1747 | Hunter | Edward elected in June | | 1634 | Marshall | Samuel |
| 1747 | Smalvell | Joseph elected in November | | 1686 | Marshall | Thomas |
| 1748 | Mason | John | | 1699 | Marshall | Thomas |
| 1749 | Argles | Thomas | | 1710 | Marshall | Thomas |
| 1750 | Stevenson | Samuel | | 1748 | Mason | John |
| 1751 | Harris | John | | 1794 | May | George |
| 1752 | Mussery | Richard | | 1839 | Mercer | John |
| 1753 | Argles | Edward | | 1848 | Mercer | John |
| 1754 | Stevenson | Samuel | | 1771 | Mercer | William |
| 1755 | Harris | John | | 1780 | Mercer | William |
| 1756 | Stevenson | Samuel | | 1582 | Milles | John |
| 1757 | Pope | Thomas | | 1551 | Mowerst | John |
| 1758 | Weldish | Jonathan | | 1553 | Mowerst | John (Charter forfeited in 1554) |
| 1759 | Polhill | Daniel | | 1563 | Mowerst | William |
| 1760 | Post | George | | 1725 | Mussery | Richard |
| 1761 | Pope | John | | 1752 | Mussery | Richard |
| 1762 | Roots | William | | 1651 | Ongley | George |
| 1763 | Lacy | Robert | | 1689 | Osborne | Alexander |
| 1764 | Holloway | Richard | | 1700 | Osborne | Alexander |
| 1765 | Post | George | | 1711 | Osborne | Alexander |
| 1766 | Holloway | Richard | | 1724 | Page | Stephen |
| 1767 | Pope | John (died Jn. 13, 1768) succeeded by David Polhill | | 1875 | Page | William |
| 1768 | Post | George | | 1683 | Peirce | George |
| 1769 | Roots | William | | 1697 | Peirce | George |
| 1770 | Holloway | Richard | | 1709 | Peirce | George |
| 1771 | Mercer | William | | 1722 | Pett | Marriott (died Nov. 13), succeeded by John Blunt |
| 1772 | Brenchley | John | | 1870 | Pine | Frederick |
| 1773 | Wrentmore | William | | 1598 | Plommer | William |
| 1774 | Pope | Robert | | 1759 | Polhill | Daniel |
| 1775 | Wrentmore | William | | 1811 | Poole | James |
| 1776 | Hammond | Tobias | | 1795 | Poole | Thomas |
| 1777 | Bishop | George | | 1804 | Poole | Thomas |
| 1778 | Bishop | William, Sir | | 1812 | Poole | Thomas |
| 1779 | Argles | Thomas | | 1761 | Pope | John |
| 1780 | Mercer | William | | 1767 | Pope | John (died Jn. 13, 1768) succeeded by David Polhill |
| 1781 | Brenchley | John | | 1774 | Pope | Robert |
| 1782 | Hammond | Tobias | | 1785 | Pope | Robert |
| 1783 | Stone | Jacob | | 1757 | Pope | Thomas |
| 1784 | Hammond | Tobias | | 1760 | Post | George |
| 1785 | Pope | Robert | | 1765 | Post | George |
| 1786 | Bishop | George | | 1768 | Post | George |
| 1787 | Bishop | William, Sir | | 1837 | Pybus | Thomas |
| 1788 | Argles | Thomas | | 1836 | Pybus | Thomas, elected in November |
| 1789 | Stone | Jacob | | 1717 | Rand | William |
| 1790 | King | John | | 1730 | Rand | William |
| 1791 | Argles | Edward | | 1841 | Randall | Alexander |
| 1792 | Stacey | Flint | | 1612 | Reeve | Thomas |
| 1793 | Day | Thomas | | 1627 | Reeve | Thomas |
| 1794 | May | George | | 1593 | Romney | John |
| 1795 | Poole | Thomas | | 1605 | Romney | John |
| 1796 | Jefferys | William | | 1762 | Roots | William |
| 1797 | Argles | Edward | | 1769 | Roots | William |
| 1798 | Stone | John | | 1647 | Ruse | James |
| 1799 | Blake | John | | 1657 | Ruse | James |
| 1800 | King | John | | 1595 | Salmon | Matthew |
| 1801 | Stacey | Flint | | 1684 | Salmon | Robert |
| 1802 | Argles | Edward | | 1698 | Salmon | Robert |
| 1803 | Day | Thomas | | 1652 | Saunders | John |
| 1804 | Poole | Thomas | | 1681 | Saunders | Robert |
| 1805 | Stone | John | | 1849 | Scudamore | Charles |
| 1806 | Blake | John | | 1705 | Sherbourne | James |
| 1807 | Cutbush | Henry | | 1713 | Sherbourne | James |
| 1808 | Burr | George | | 1854 | Simmonds | Henry |
| 1809 | Burgess | George | | 1747 | Smalvell | Joseph elected in November |
| 1810 | Day | Thomas | | 1881 | Smith | E. B. |
| 1811 | Poole | James | | 1564 | Smyth | William |
| 1812 | Poole | Thomas | | 1590 | Smythe | Richard |
| 1813 | Stone | John | | 1880 | Spencer | Alfred |
| 1814 | Corrall | Philip | | 1599 | Spencer | James |
| 1815 | Argles | John | | 1828 | Stacey | Courtenay |
| 1816 | Brenchley | John | | 1822 | Stacey | Coutenay |
| 1817 | Day | John | | 1844 | Stacey | Edwin |
| 1818 | Stacey | William Henry | | 1792 | Stacey | Flint |
| 1819 | Mares | John | | 1801 | Stacey | Flint |
| 1820 | Wise | John | | 1818 | Stacey | William Henry |
| 1821 | Burgess | George | | 1827 | Stacey | William Henry |
| 1822 | Stacey | Coutenay | | 1834 | Stacey | William Henry |
| 1823 | Tassell | Robert | | 1835 | Stacey | William Henry |
| 1824 | Hughes | John N. | | 1625 | Stanley | Thomas |
| 1825 | Wise | John | | 1641 | Stanley | Thomas |
| 1826 | Mares | John | | 1572 | Staylett | John |
| 1827 | Stacey | William Henry | | 1859 | Stephens | John Cribb |
| 1828 | Stacey | Courtenay | | 1739 | Stevenson | Samuel |
| 1829 | Tassell | Robert | | 1750 | Stevenson | Samuel |
| 1830 | Hughes | John N. | | 1754 | Stevenson | Samuel |
| 1831 | Day | Thomas | | 1756 | Stevenson | Samuel |
| 1832 | Hills | Walter | | 1783 | Stone | Jacob |
| 1833 | Mares | John | | 1789 | Stone | Jacob |
| 1834 | Stacey | William Henry | | 1798 | Stone | John |
| 1835 | Stacey | William Henry | | 1805 | Stone | John |
| 1836 | Ellis | Charles, elected in January | | 1813 | Stone | John |
| 1836 | Pybus | Thomas, elected in November | | 1630 | Swinnock | Robert |
| 1837 | Pybus | Thomas | | 1643 | Swinnock | Robert |
| 1838 | Hussey | William | | 1692 | Swinnock | Robert |
| 1839 | Mercer | John | | 1611 | Swinnock | Thomas |
| 1840 | Franklyn | Thomas | | 1619 | Swinnock | Thomas |
| 1841 | Randall | Alexander | | 1626 | Swinnock | Thomas |
| 1842 | Edmett | Thomas | | 1638 | Swinnock | Thomas |
| 1843 | Day | Thomas | | 1586 | Symmonds | William |
| 1844 | Stacey | Edwin | | 1823 | Tassell | Robert |
| 1845 | Argles | Henry | | 1829 | Tassell | Robert |
| 1846 | Franklyn | Thomas | | 1649 | Taylor | Thomas |
| 1847 | Whichoord | John | | 1552 | Tilden | William |
| 1848 | Mercer | John | | 1720 | Tomlyn | John |
| 1849 | Scudamore | Charles | | 1733 | Tomlyn | John |
| 1850 | Tootell | Joseph | | 1850 | Tootell | Joseph |
| 1851 | Haynes | William | | 1655 | Troughton | Jonathan |
| 1852 | Joy | Henry Winkles | | 1585 | Tynley | Robert |
| 1853 | Laurence | William | | 1673 | Venman | Thomas |
| 1854 | Simmonds | Henry | | 1677 | Walker | George |
| 1855 | Argles | Henry | | 1688 | Wattell | Richard |
| 1856 | Whichoord | John | | 1726 | Wattell | William |
| 1857 | Wickham | George | | 1691 | Weaver | William |
| 1858 | Arkcoll | Charles | | 1701 | Weaver | William |
| 1859 | Stephens | John Cribb | | 1704 | Weeks | Stephen |
| 1860 | Ellis | Charles | | 1758 | Weldish | Jonathan |
| 1861 | Haynes | William | | 1678 | Weldish | William |
| 1862 | Edmett | George | | 1694 | Weldish | William |
| 1863 | Clifford | James | | 1706 | Weldish | William |
| 1864 | Ellis | Charles, Jr. | | 1728 | Weldish | William |
| 1865 | Laurence | William | | 1736 | Weldish | William |
| 1866 | Cutbush | Horace R. | | 1737 | Weldish | William |
| 1867 | Edmett | George | | 1738 | Weldish | William |
| 1868 | Arkcoll | Charles | | 1727 | Whetland | Daniel |
| 1869 | Haynes | William | | 1847 | Whichoord | John |
| 1870 | Pine | Frederick | | 1856 | Whichoord | John |
| 1871 | Hills | John H. | | 1857 | Wickham | George |
| 1872 | Ellis | Charles | | 1820 | Wise | John |
| 1873 | Clifford | James | | 1825 | Wise | John |
| 1874 | Hughes | Henry | | 1642 | Withinbroke | Robert |
| 1875 | Page | William | | 1631 | Wood | Robert |
| 1876 | Youngman | George | | 1675 | Wood | Samuel |
| 1877 | Haynes | William | | 1693 | Wood | Samuel |
| 1878 | Ellis | Charles | | 1773 | Wrentmore | William |
| 1879 | Day | William, Jr. | | 1775 | Wrentmore | William |
| 1880 | Spencer | Alfred | | 1687 | Wright | Joseph, a Baptist Minister, elected Oct. 1688 Robert Saunders |
| 1881 | Smith | E. B. | | 1876 | Youngman | George |